J.J. McCarthy NFL Draft Profile

 

J.J McCarthy Scouting Report

J.J. McCarthy, the Michigan Wolverine’s starting Quarterback, is already demonstrating a passing arm worthy of the NFL level. McCarthy, who recently passed fellow Michigan alumni and NFL legend, Tom Brady’s school passing record, has proven he can throw the deep ball and every throw in between with amazing accuracy and velocity. So far, McCarthy has completed 78.1% of his passes, which is the second-highest rate in the Big 10 Conference. McCarthy has the potential to challenge for early-round capital and maybe earn a chance as a presumed franchise QB in Round 1. However, he is not currently considered one of the top quarterback prospects in the 2024 NFL Draft.

Instead, the top quarterback prospects in the 2024 NFL Draft are Caleb Williams from USC, Drake Maye from North Carolina, and Leonard from San Diego State. But if McCarthy can lead the third-ranked Wolverines to the National Championship game, not only will his Heisman stock rise but so should his NFL Draft stock. It’s clear that he has a promising career ahead of him. Let’s break down some key points.

2024 NFL Draft Measurements

6’3″ 202 lbs.

 

Strengths

Accurate Deep Ball Thrower

McCarthy’s physical attributes, including his height and frame, make him a formidable presence on the field. His mechanics and athleticism are advanced for his age, which bodes well for his transition to the NFL. His ability to make accurate throws even in tight coverage situations. He uses a sidearm delivery like former NFL MVP and former Raiders Quarterback, Rich Gannon, to protect his passing window. This is a valuable skill and makes him the center of attention for sports betting in Michigan.

Tremendous Pocket Presence

One of the reasons why so many dominant college football quarterbacks struggle in the NFL, is pocket awareness. For a junior, McCarthy has consistently demonstrated that he can read defenses like a veteran NFL quarterback.

Fast Passer

In addition to outstanding pocket awareness, McCarthy has NFL-ready mechanics despite being a junior. His athleticism and scrambling ability helps Michigan’s offense score more often than not and tire out defenses. While not on the same level as Dan Marino’s legendary pass releases, McCarthy already has noticeable passing speed, even through tight coverage. This skill will help him avoid unnecessary sacks and possibly lead to a long NFL career.

Weaknesses

Lean

While he has a strong frame, his lean build was noted as a weakness. Being able to take NFL-level hits consistently has to be proven for NFL scouts to consider the draft investment. However, it’s mentioned that efforts have been made to improve his weight. Unless McCarthy proves he can handle physical defenses, he is bound to struggle with fierce NFL defenses that rely on heavy pressure.

Draft Projection

McCarthy’s draft projection has evolved since his time at Michigan, and he is now considered a potential first-round pick in the NFL Draft. CBS Sports even predicts him as a potential ninth-overall pick. This is a significant testament to his improved abilities and a Heisman-worthy junior season. If McCarthy finishes strong or indeed wins the Heisman, the scouts won’t have any choice but to put him in the mix with Maye and Caleb Williams.

McCarthy’s Future

If Michigan’s sign-stealing scandal doesn’t distract the Wolverines, expect McCarthy to finish strong. Hopefully with a bowl win under his belt. McCarthy’s prospects in both college football and the NFL look promising. His continued success on the field will likely determine his ultimate trajectory in the sport.